Perhaps because I grew up between cultures and, inevitably,
was always perceived as Other, I have never felt bound to my stereotypically
defined roles. As a child and adolescent I grew up surrounded by “Third
Culture” individuals: people who, like me, had lived in different places, had
been disassociated from their native country, and had turned into something new
that belonged within no national boundaries. It was a space where people held
on to a vague sense of nationality but in the end embraced a larger, more
inclusive, sense of self. Not being trapped within these confines meant that
anything was possible.
I have always done what has interested me and, as I have
discovered recently, this has made me very difficult to categorize. By
inadvertently defying categorization, I have triggered many different responses
in people – ranging from an interest to pursue non-conventional hobbies to a pro-stereotyping
defensive stance. Over the past few months, it has been brought to my attention
that my combined interests in fashion (borderline shopaholic) and martial arts
are simply inconceivable. For the most part, the negative reactions have come
due to a perceived threat to masculinity. I never have pursued something
because of a specified gender convention and the idea that practicing a martial
art can be a threat to someone’s masculinity seems irrational. Is a man who can
sew or dance ballet threatening to my femininity? No.
From the comments I have heard, it seems like my martial
hobbies would be more acceptable if I were a “masculine” woman – whatever that
means. This makes me feel that challenging gender norms is usually perceived as
objectionable but that if other stereotyping conventions can come into play, it
can be tolerable. However, if stereotyping is completely unhelpful in building
a perception of an individual, than the gender-defying activity is seen as
increasingly unacceptable. This reaction points to an overall reliance on
stereotypes in “creating” the people we meet. Ultimately, the stereotype allows
someone to not spend time meeting another person, but instead makes them feel
an immediate familiarity with everyone they encounter. In essence stereotyping
allows for each individual to construct their own reality that does not truly
mirror the actual world they inhabit.
For more information about what a Third Culture individual
is check out this website: http://www.denizenmag.com/third-culture-kid/
I was thinking of stereotypes the other day thanks to Hulu. As a woman in my mid-late twenties apparently all I want is Tylenol for my baby, paper towels to clean up after my messy but adorably lovable children, and products to keep my house clean. Oh, and of course cosmetics and hair care products. Thanks . . . they clearly don't want to build a detailed perception of who I am before trying to sell things to me.
ReplyDeleteI really like your comment about stereotyping allowing people "to construct their own reality." That's a great insight.
I agree with much of what you said. I think from a psychological standpoint stereotypes are necessary... how else are we supposed to interpret all the new people and things we meet everyday.
ReplyDeleteHowever, while stereotypes can help categorize, they should not be limiting. As you mention, you do not fit into the typical images... thus in my opinion, we should learn to make new ones! Our minds have infinite capabilities, we will survive if we think outside the box every so often.